Disability Rights California Lawsuit against Alameda County

Disability Rights California Lawsuit against Alameda County
Disability Rights California (DRC), along with Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, the Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law, Goldstein, Borgen, Dardarian & Ho, and the Law Office of Aaron J. Fischer have filed a federal lawsuit under the Americans with Disabilities Act against Alameda County and Alameda County Behavioral Health Care Services. The lawsuit challenges the unnecessary and illegal segregation of people with mental health disabilities- especially Black people with disabilities in psychiatric institutions and the failure to ensure people with disabilities are provided the services they need.
DRC is demanding that the County expand and enhance intensive community-based mental health services, including supported housing, so that people are not forced into institutions like John George Psychiatric Hospital, or the Santa Rita Jail, when they can be served in a more integrated setting.
Case Name:
Disability Rights California v. County of Alameda
Court and Case Number:
5:20-cv-05256 (N.D. Cal.)
Co-Counsel:
Bazelon Center for Mental Health Law
Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund
Law Office of Aaron J. Fischer
Goldstein, Borgen, Dardarian & Ho
Independent Reviewer Reports on the County’s Implementation of the Settlement Agreement
Under the Settlement Agreement, the Independent Reviewer will draft comprehensive public reports on the County’s progress and implementation of the Agreement. The Independent Reviewer will also provide recommendations, if any, for achieving sustained substantial compliance with the terms of the Agreement. The Agreement requires that the Reviewer submit five reports no later than six (6), fourteen (14), twenty (20), twenty-five (25), and thirty-one (31) months after the Effective Date of the Agreement.
- Dr. Karen Baylor, Six-Month Report, Submitted August 7, 2024 (pdf)
- Dr. Karen Baylor, 14-Month Report, Submitted April 14, 2025 (pdf)
Significant Case Documents
- Settlement Agreement Between DRC, Alameda County, and the United States (pdf)
- DOJ Report - Notice Regarding Investigation of Alameda County
- Amended Complaint (pdf)
- Complaint (pdf)
- Notice Regarding Investigation of Alameda County, John George Psychiatric Hospital, and Santa Rita Jail (pdf)
Press Release
- Settlement Reached Between Disability Rights California, the County of Alameda, and the United States Department of Justice to Strengthen the County’s Behavioral Health System
- Disability Rights California Files Lawsuit against Alameda County for Its Failed Mental Health System
News Coverage
- Alameda County faces court decree to improve jail’s treatment of inmates with mental health issues - The Mercury News 09/08/2021
- Alameda County jail’s mental health care would be overhauled under proposed lawsuit settlement - The Oakland Side - 08/30/2021
- Alameda County violates rights of mental health patients, inmates, feds say - San Fransisco Chronicle 04/25/2021
- Justice Department: Alameda County violates rights of mental health patients, inmates - Voice of America 04/23/2021
- When Going to the Hospital Is Just as Bad as Jail - The Marshall Project 11/8/20