Our Vision Statement: Disability Rights California will create individual and family supports, chosen and directed by the person with a disability

Justice for All

August 14, 2009

Disability community denounces rationing argument in NYT

Not Dead Yet and coalition denounce New York Times Magazine article

Logo: Not Dead Yet

WASHINGTON, DC – August 14, 2009 – Not Dead Yet, along with more than 40 other disability organizations, including the American Association of People with Disabilities (AAPD), has signed on to a letter to New York Times Magazine Editor Gerald Marzorati denouncing a July 15 article by ethicist Peter Singer.  Singer’s article argued for rationing health care by denying treatments to people with disabilities based on the assumption that our lives have less value than the lives of nondisabled people.

“For The New York Times Magazine to publish an article calling for health care rationing that would discriminate against people with disabilities one week before the anniversary of the Americans with Disabilities Act shows how out of touch the leadership at The New York Times Magazine is,” said Not Dead Yet President Diane Coleman. “Peter Singer is a sloppy ethicist who should not be given a forum by a publication as credible as The New York Times. His piece, published at a key time in the health care debate, gives fodder to critics whose goal is to kill any reform by raising the specter of government supported euthanasia.”

The letter, written by Stephen Drake, Research Analyst for Not Dead Yet, states:

“…This is Peter Singer’s most direct assault on the value of the lives of people with physical disabilities past the age of infancy that we have read. His policy proposals allowing for the killing of newborns with disabilities and people with significant cognitive disabilities are already well known.

While this is a bolder assault than we have seen from Professor Singer in the past, it’s hardly surprising. What’s surprising and deeply disturbing is that the NY Times editorial staff have sought him out as a writer on more than one occasion...”

The coalition has requested the following of The New York Times Magazine:

1. The NY Times staff needs to define and clarify its understanding of disability as a basic human rights issue.

2. If the current stance of the NY Times is that the lives of people with disabilities are, in fact, a drain on health care sources, it should be stated on record.

3. Discuss training in the basics of covering disability in news stories – beyond the “human interest” and “medical” angles.

4. Cover the difference between “analysis” and “appealing to bigotry” in public policy discussions.

To read the letter in its entirety, visit http://notdeadyetnewscommentary.blogspot.com. For more information about AAPD’s views on the Peter Singer piece in The New York Times, please visit www.aapd.com.

Not Dead Yet, 497 State St., Rochester, NY 14608
Phone: 585-697-1640; Fax: 585-697-1641
Email: sndrake@aol.com
Web: http://www.notdeadyet.org